Pros and cons


Pros

Many of the advantages of the accelerometry and heart rate monitoring are summated in combined heart rate and motion measurement.

  • Provides an objective measure of total physical activity
  • Provides an accurate estimate of energy expenditure during physical activity
  • Combined measurement has been shown to be reliable and valid at both individual and group level
  • Gives a detailed description of activity patterns
  • Combined devices have storage capacity of at least 7 days
  • Able to detect change in activity
  • Unlikely to induce a large change in behaviour
  • Single-piece devices involve a reasonably low individual burden
  • Suitable for use in the young and old
  • Easy and quick for data collection and analysis
  • Non wearing time easily identified
  • Waterproof
  • Reasonably low level calibration can yield accuracy suitable for epidemiological studies
  • Using the combined approach means that many of the drawbacks when the methods are used in isolation are overcome

Cons

  • Combined devices are expensive
  • The data produced from either combined devices or the single methods used simultaneously are complex and requires careful interpretation and guidance from others experienced in the method. This is particularly true for dealing with measurement noise in HR recordings
  • Combining a heart rate monitor with a separate accelerometer imposes a reasonable individual burden
  • Compliance may be difficult in some populations especially adolescents
  • If using electrodes individuals may experience an adverse skin reaction to these

 

Web design by Studio 24